Parcourir la source

Fixat en massa punkter, men ännu inte allt.

Jonatan Gezelius il y a 4 ans
Parent
commit
5a8a9c084b

+ 25 - 0
opponering/kommentarer på mitt/kommentarer på kommentarer.txt

@@ -0,0 +1,25 @@
+
+* Jag kallar Test pulse 1 annorlunda?
+	Använt versaler annorlunda. Det är inget speciellt med ordet, så tar bort versal när den inte står i början av mening.
+
+* Fixa ihop tabeller och figurer för pulser
+
+* Isolated differential probe
+
+* 3.3 1k = inf
+
+* Figure 3.8 ??
+
+* Sprid ut figur 3.9
+
+* Figure 3.10
+  isolation != insulation
+
+==== Behandlat
+* Publiceringsdatum?
+* S21 som S_21? (Figur 4.9-4.11)
+* Disturbance är det ord som används i standarden
+* Allt var fel i tabell 2.5, copy-pastefel. Fixat.
+* Saknar referens till vishay i 2.5. Flyttat referensen till första förekomsten.
+* formel 2.2. Jag förstår inte härledningen :)
+* Fixat legend till figurerna med kablar

+ 2 - 2
rapport/abstract.tex

@@ -31,9 +31,9 @@
 %% 
 %%% Code:
 % !TeX root = main.tex
-Standards exist to unify requirements and to make it possible to make sure that equipment is tested in the same way, even if several different test labs performs the test. But as new technology comes to market, and old technology evolves, so must the standards. The International Organization for Standardization are continuously developing new standards and updating existing standards. And sometimes the specified tests changes, yielding old test equipment obsolete.
+Standards exist to unify requirements and to make it possible to make sure that equipment is tested in the same way, even if several different test labs perform the test. But as new technology comes to market, and old technology evolves, so must the standards. The International Organization for Standardization are continuously developing new standards and updating existing standards, and sometimes the specified tests changes, rendering old test equipment obsolete.
 
-In this thesis, we will look at the differences between the old and the current versions of the ISO~7637 standards as well as how we can verify if old test equipment lives up to the new requirements. A verification method will be designed, partly implemented and evaluated. Several of the aspects for automating the verification will be considered. The results will show that old equipment most likely will be usable with the newer version of the standard, as well as point out some of the difficulties of verifyng that this is the case.
+In this thesis, we will look at the differences between the old and the current versions of the ISO~7637 standards as well as how we can verify if old test equipment lives up to the new requirements. A verification method will be designed, partly implemented and evaluated. Several of the aspects for automating the verification will be considered. The results will show that old equipment most likely will be usable with the newer version of the standard, as well as point out some of the difficulties of verifying that this is the case.
 
 
 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%

+ 1 - 1
rapport/discussion.tex

@@ -67,7 +67,7 @@ The methods that need further explanation and reflections are presented here.
 
 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
 \subsection{Components}
-It was surprisingly difficult to find and choose the appropriate components for the dummy load. The resistors had to tolerate extreme surges and the relays had to have high insulation voltages between the contacts. Even finding the encapsulation for the relay box proved to be a challenge, since the filtering options available in the retailer's web stores were not always consistent.
+It was surprisingly difficult to find and choose the appropriate components for the dummy load. The resistors had to tolerate extreme surges and the relays had to withstand high voltages between the contacts. Even finding the encapsulation for the relay box proved to be a challenge, since the filtering options available in the retailer's web stores were not always consistent.
 
 The usage of the energy curve in the datasheet might have been wrong. In this work, the total accumulated energy from time $t=0$ was considered, but a more reasonable approach would be to test all starting points to find the most extreme energy curve.
 

+ 1 - 1
rapport/figures/draw/manual-measurement-hv-diff-cna.drawio

@@ -1 +1 @@
-<mxfile modified="2020-08-09T20:19:27.555Z" host="draw.jegatron.se" agent="Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64; rv:79.0) Gecko/20100101 Firefox/79.0" etag="EJZqkh3t49JM8SO82vvg" pages="1" version="11.2.8" type="device"><diagram id="v6DM7zrvzqAhAaCDu8FQ" name="Page-1">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</diagram></mxfile>
+<mxfile modified="2021-02-27T09:54:35.192Z" host="draw.jegatron.se" agent="Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64; rv:85.0) Gecko/20100101 Firefox/85.0" etag="ibDybSvKgvifspVTylzJ" pages="1" version="11.2.8" type="device"><diagram id="v6DM7zrvzqAhAaCDu8FQ" name="Page-1">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</diagram></mxfile>

+ 1 - 1
rapport/figures/draw/manual-measurement-hv-diff.drawio

@@ -1 +1 @@
-<mxfile modified="2020-08-09T20:20:18.372Z" host="draw.jegatron.se" agent="Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64; rv:79.0) Gecko/20100101 Firefox/79.0" etag="4yIYXHlDujktLKxFxptW" pages="1" version="11.2.8" type="device"><diagram id="v6DM7zrvzqAhAaCDu8FQ" name="Page-1">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</diagram></mxfile>
+<mxfile modified="2021-02-27T09:15:29.584Z" host="draw.jegatron.se" agent="Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64; rv:85.0) Gecko/20100101 Firefox/85.0" etag="Liyy7C0RBoVJP8Q4KQre" pages="1" version="11.2.8" type="device"><diagram id="v6DM7zrvzqAhAaCDu8FQ" name="Page-1">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</diagram></mxfile>

Fichier diff supprimé car celui-ci est trop grand
+ 0 - 0
rapport/figures/draw/test setup automatic external.drawio


Fichier diff supprimé car celui-ci est trop grand
+ 0 - 0
rapport/figures/draw/test setup automatic internal.drawio


Fichier diff supprimé car celui-ci est trop grand
+ 0 - 0
rapport/figures/draw/test setup human assisted.drawio


Fichier diff supprimé car celui-ci est trop grand
+ 0 - 0
rapport/figures/draw/test setup pulse injection.drawio


+ 1 - 1
rapport/figures/draw/test_equipment_setup.drawio

@@ -1 +1 @@
-<mxfile modified="2020-08-07T17:03:43.954Z" host="draw.jegatron.se" agent="Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64; rv:79.0) Gecko/20100101 Firefox/79.0" etag="WsWVcB94bqDF93AlhziQ" version="11.2.8" type="device" pages="1"><diagram id="ZXyMGBmr7NdsFzUsQr0I" name="Page-1">7VjbctowEP0aP6ZjW5jLY4HQziSdoUMyvbypeLHVCsuV5WDy9ZWwZGNE0pA4QGbCA2MdSWvp7NnVWg4aLYtPHKfxFxYCdXw3LBw0dny/33HlvwLWJdBVLQVEnIQl5NXAjNyDBvW8KCchZI2BgjEqSNoE5yxJYC4aGOacrZrDFow235riCCxgNsfURr+RUMR6W4Fb45+BRLF5s+fqniU2gzWQxThkqy0IXTpoxBkT5dOyGAFV3BleynmTB3qrhXFIxFMm0OnVFVvM/Z9ej371yC2554sLT5u5wzTXO9arFWtDAWd5EoKy4jpouIqJgFmK56p3JX0usVgsqWx58nHBEqG96A1Um1A6YpRxCSQskfgwE5z9qdhEEtFrAC6geHB3XsWZ1BqwJQi+lkP0BN8ITevMM7Svaq+hnsbiLY8h4zCslRJVtmsy5YPm8wBukcUkhFJbusm4iFnEEkwva3TY5Loec81Yqhn+DUKsNcU4F6zJPxREfN96/qFMffAD3RwX2vSmsdaNXadBEn5UsVP7TCITorZfjTdOdRSD6ld5dqtnMmn0GJ93Kp8rRh73uCSQ5XwOj4l4vzI4UCzIXdP+Pi/rqVNG5JsrRfVQU1FVIBsTAvMIhJ61o5VqGc+XT+d85NNrVz6WTHYEZGQSvEmZdI8rk+CUMnHfs8wL5VOdUyfKMt3zkc97ljlAJkfOMnaZeD29kLWdAN5avei7LZWC/R2uXLsU7O+pBPuvVQj2zyfGnh1iTLq+EWLGeS/J0N3Son7loN1A9F8lENGuuI6crwfnUxU+rqWnaGdba4ek6zemmeDEydu3kvc0pxmo2xVIgGPB7CQuzZI0g/8ncJyl5b3LghRKY5ZjW8joHbdJINrzcT8I7IxusNYzes9mdHbb2kGIbNW3dEuy+62y52QcHPNkNLd8W0SOb2/eAJHWV9+pawzPDvIbyFQSgr85SZegU8s2rXL7oskdh4zc41+bAYq7VKWkzVKDoROMVbjLwyHT0a2alESJfKawUKYUp2SO6UcNC3XADDPpK5JEN5vT5qKzx0cPFRJtSH4n+XrI9pQX7L0YPNhVslnf55bZu74UR5f/AA==</diagram></mxfile>
+<mxfile modified="2021-02-18T19:54:36.181Z" host="draw.jegatron.se" agent="Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0; Win64; x64; rv:85.0) Gecko/20100101 Firefox/85.0" etag="JsQJuOM6YIFSzRLySMLB" pages="1" version="11.2.8" type="device"><diagram id="ZXyMGBmr7NdsFzUsQr0I" name="Page-1">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</diagram></mxfile>

BIN
rapport/figures/manual-measurement-hv-diff-cna.png


BIN
rapport/figures/manual-measurement-hv-diff.png


BIN
rapport/figures/test setup automatic external.png


BIN
rapport/figures/test setup automatic internal.png


BIN
rapport/figures/test setup human assisted.png


BIN
rapport/figures/test setup pulse injection.png


BIN
rapport/figures/test_equipment_setup.png


+ 5 - 5
rapport/intro.tex

@@ -34,12 +34,12 @@
 \chapter{Introduction}\label{cha:intro}
 The standards ISO~7637, \emph{Road vehicles -- Electrical disturbances from conduction and coupling}, and ISO~16750, \emph{Road vehicles -- Environmental conditions and testing for electrical and electronic equipment}, are international standards that apply to equipment in road vehicles with a nominal supply voltage of \SI{12}{\volt} or \SI{24}{\volt}.
 
-The standards states that the product shall withstand a sufficient amount of disturbances applied to its power supply. The reason for this beeing that there can be voltage surges and noise in a vehicle's power supply lines. In general, the source of disturbances and noise in a vehicle origins from inductance in other devices connected to the power line, the cables and the vehicles alternator in combination with switching of loads or the supply. \cite{iso_7637_2, iso_16750_2}
+The standards state that the product shall withstand a certain level of disturbances applied to its power supply. The reason for this being that there can be voltage surges and noise in a vehicle's power supply lines. In general, the source of disturbances and noise in a vehicle originates from inductance in other devices connected to the power line, the cables and the vehicles alternator in combination with switching of loads or the supply. \cite{iso_7637_2, iso_16750_2}
 
-To test if a product comply with this standard, there is equipment that simulates different events on the power supply lines. The test events consists of voltage pulses that are applied to the DUT, device under test. The pulses of interest in this paper are denoted pulse 1, pulse 2a, pulse 3a, pulse 3b and load dump test A. The standard defines the different scenarios, raise and fall times of test pulses, repetition times etc. It also defines the functional requirements of the equipment during these tests for what is considered a passed or a failed test. \cite{iso_7637_2, iso_16750_2}
+To test if a product complies with this standard, there is equipment that simulates different events on the power supply lines. The test events consist of voltage pulses that are applied to the DUT, device under test. The pulses of interest in this paper are denoted pulse 1, pulse 2a, pulse 3a, pulse 3b and load dump test A. The standard defines different scenarios, raise and fall times of test pulses, repetition times, etc. It also defines the functional requirements of the equipment during these tests for what is considered a passed or a failed test. \cite{iso_7637_2, iso_16750_2}
 
 \section{Motivation}
-The standard defines all the timing requirements that must be met, and also specifies the load conditions for which the requirements apply \cite{iso_7637_2}. From time to time the standards are revised, which may alter the requirements form the previous versions of the standard. Test equipment might be constructed for the currently valid standards, and possibly older versions, but might not be compatible with newer versions. New equipment might not be affordable by smaller test labs, and can thus inhibit labs from performing tests for this standard.
+The standard defines all the timing requirements that must be met and also specifies the load conditions for which the requirements apply \cite{iso_7637_2}. From time to time the standards are revised, which may alter the requirements form the previous versions of the standard. Test equipment might be constructed for the currently valid standards, and possibly older versions, but might not be compatible with newer versions. New equipment might not be affordable by smaller test labs and can thus inhibit labs from performing tests for this standard.
 
 An appealing alternative would be the possibility to reuse the test equipment that was used along with the older revision of the standard, as long as it is capable of performing the tests reliably. For this to be possible, the test equipment must be verified in some way so that it is possible to guarantee that the tests are performed according to the new standard.
 
@@ -58,13 +58,13 @@ The following questions will be answered in this paper:
 \begin{enumerate}
     \item{Can test equipment made for ISO 7637-2:2004, be used for testing compliance against ISO 7637-2:2011, the newer version of the standard?}
     \item{If it can; What considerations must be made to allow for automating the test and verification process?}
-    \item{If it can't; What causes the failure, and what possible fixes can be made to make the equipment usable for the newer standard?}
+    \item{If it cannot; What causes the failure, and what possible fixes can be made to make the equipment usable for the newer standard?}
 \end{enumerate}
 
 \section{Delimitations}
 This paper only compares the standard ISO 7637\nd2:2004 to ISO 7637\nd2:2011 and ISO~16750\nd2:2012, because these are the most recent versions of the standards.
 
-This paper only considers Pulse 1, Pulse 2a, Pulse 3a, Pulse 3b and Load dump A. The main reason being that these are the pulses that the available equipment can generate, but also that these pulses share many properties and the method of analysing them will probably be very similar.
+This paper only considers pulse 1, pulse 2a, pulse 3a, pulse 3b and load dump A. The main reason being that these are the pulses that the available equipment can generate, but also that these pulses share many properties and the method of analysing them will probably be very similar.
 
 This paper only considers the test equipment for ISO~7637-2 that was available at the company, presented in \autoref{tab:used_equipment}, for the pratical tests.
 \begin{table}[H]

+ 4 - 3
rapport/liuthesis.cls

@@ -680,7 +680,8 @@
 \fi
 
 \ifstudent
-\newcommand{\isrn}{LIU-\@departmentshort{}/\@area{}-EX-\@level{}-{}-\@publicationyear/\@currentyearthesisnumber-{}-SE}
+%\newcommand{\isrn}{LIU-\@departmentshort{}/\@area{}-EX-\@level{}-{}-\@publicationyear/\@currentyearthesisnumber-{}-SE}
+\newcommand{\isrn}{LiTH-\@departmentshort{}-EX-\@level{}-{}-\@publicationyear/\@currentyearthesisnumber-{}-SE}
 \fi
 
 \newcommand\makeundergraduatetitle{%
@@ -691,13 +692,13 @@
       \begin{large}%
         Linköpings universitet | \@department\par
         Examensarbete på \@thesistypenameswedish, \@thesiscredits hp | \@thesissubject\par%
-        20\@publicationyear\ | \isrn\par%
+        \@dateofpublication\ | \isrn\par%
       \end{large}%
       }{%
       \begin{large}%
         Linköping University | \@departmentenglish\par
         \@thesistypenameenglish{} thesis, \@thesiscredits{} ECTS | \@thesissubject\par%
-        20\@publicationyear\ | \isrn\par%
+        \@dateofpublication\ | \isrn\par%
       \end{large}%
       }%
       }%

BIN
rapport/main.pdf


+ 2 - 2
rapport/main.tex

@@ -126,9 +126,9 @@
 \titleswedish{Återanvändning och verifiering av testutrustning för ISO 7637}
 \thesissubject{Electronics}
 
-\publicationyear{2021}
+\publicationyear{21}
 \currentyearthesisnumber{0501}
-\dateofpublication{2021-02-20}
+\dateofpublication{2021}
 
 \author{Jonatan Gezelius}
 

+ 32 - 29
rapport/method.tex

@@ -36,11 +36,11 @@ This chapter covers the methodologies used during the project.
 
 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
 \section{Prestudy}
-During the project efforts were made to find relevant research using Linköping University Library's\footnote{\url{https://liu.se/en/library}} and Google Scholar's\footnote{\url{https://scholar.google.se/}} search engines.
+During the project efforts were made to find relevant research using Linköping University Library's\footnote{\url{https://liu.se/en/library/}} and Google Scholar's\footnote{\url{https://scholar.google.se/}} search engines.
 
 Since the equipment intended for this project was untested before the project start, the first step was to hook it up and make some initial measurements to be able to decide the continuation of the project.
 
-If the equipment seem to be mostly in line with the new standard requirements, the project plan was to go along the following path:
+If the equipment is in line with the new standard requirements, the project will go along the following path:
 \begin{enumerate}
     \item Investigate test architectures suitable for automatic testing and verification.
     \item Design any utilities needed for the test and verification setup.
@@ -48,7 +48,7 @@ If the equipment seem to be mostly in line with the new standard requirements, t
     \item Measure and evaluate the system and the utilities.
 \end{enumerate}
 
-If the equipment proved to deviate to much from the standard requirement, the project should go along the following path:
+If the equipment deviates from the new standard requirements, the project will go along the following path:
 \begin{enumerate}
     \item Investigate possible causes and fixes for the failure.
     \item Design any utilities needed for the equipment to pass.
@@ -69,11 +69,11 @@ Since the equipment used in the project is designed for the older version of the
 
 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
 \section{Examination and initial measurement of the old equipment}
-To decide the forthcoming of the project, the equipment first had to be checked to see if it is capable to operate within the limits for use with the newer standard. Because there is no dummy loads available at this point of the project, only open load measurements could be done.
+To decide the continuation of the project, the equipment first had to be inspected to see if it is capable to operate within the limits for use with the newer standard. This was done as a verification as specified by the standard, described in \autoref{sec:theory:verification}. Only the open load measurements could be done, since no dummy loads were available at this time in the project.
 
 With exception for Pulse 3a and Pulse 3b, all of the pulses were measured with the use of the high voltage differential probe described in \autoref{sec:hv-diff-probe}. The pulses are measured both directly on each generator connected according to \autoref{fig:manual-measurement-hv-diff} and also through the coupling network CNA~200, as depicted in \autoref{fig:manual-measurement-hv-diff-cna}.
 
-\begin{figure}
+\begin{figure}[H]
 	\centering
 	\begin{subfigure}[t]{0.5\textwidth}
 		\includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{manual-measurement-hv-diff}
@@ -86,12 +86,12 @@ With exception for Pulse 3a and Pulse 3b, all of the pulses were measured with t
 		\caption{With CNA.}
    	    \label{fig:manual-measurement-hv-diff-cna}
 	\end{subfigure}
-	\caption{The setup for measuring for pulse 1, pulse 2a and Load dump A.}
+	\caption{The setup for measuring for test pulse 1, test pulse 2a and load dump test A.}
 \end{figure}
 
-Pulse 3a and Pulse 3b was measured using the attenuators described in \autoref{sec:hv-attenuators} connected directly to the coaxial connector according to \autoref{fig:manual-measurement-hv-att} without the CNA. They were also measured connected through the CNA, directly to the coaxial connector according to \autoref{fig:manual-measurement-hv-att-cna}. Thanks to the 50-ohm attenuator, PAT-50, this pulse could be measured in its matched state. The measurement in open state is a compromise, since a passive attenuator that does not load the input would be impossible to make, and was made as a 1000-ohm attenuator instead.
+Test pulse 3a and 3b was measured using the attenuators described in \autoref{sec:hv-attenuators} connected directly to the coaxial connector according to \autoref{fig:manual-measurement-hv-att} without the CNA. They were also measured connected through the CNA, directly to the coaxial connector according to \autoref{fig:manual-measurement-hv-att-cna}. Thanks to the 50-ohm attenuator, PAT-50, this pulse could be measured in its matched state. 
 
-\begin{figure}
+\begin{figure}[H]
 	\centering
 	\begin{subfigure}[t]{0.45\textwidth}
 		\includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{manual-measurement-hv-att}
@@ -108,21 +108,22 @@ Pulse 3a and Pulse 3b was measured using the attenuators described in \autoref{s
 
 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
 \section{Test architecture}
-The total number of tests needed to verify the testing equipment before each product test is 14, according to \autoref{tab:verification-list}. There are in total three different values for dummy loads. In practice these could be represented by two high frequency attenuators for pulse 3a and pulse 3b, since these have really short rise times that will be affected much by parasitics of components, and three different high power dummy loads for the slower pulses where the parasitic effects might be negligible but the withstand power must be higher.
+The total number of tests needed to verify the testing equipment before each product test is 14, according to \autoref{tab:verification-list}. There are in total three different values for dummy loads. In practice these could be represented by two high frequency attenuators for pulse 3a and pulse 3b, since these have really short rise times that will be affected much by parasitics of components, and three different high power dummy loads for the slower pulses where the parasitic effects might be negligible but the ability to withstand power must be higher.
 
-The following test architectures were considered, together with the external supervisor at the company.
+The following test architectures were considered, together with the external supervisor at the company. The company has a testing framework that is capable of controlling GPIB-compatible equipment which will be used to control the generators and measurement equipment in the future.
 
 Additionally there needs to be some sort of measurement fixture for evaluating the verification equipment.
 
 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
 \subsection{Alternative 1 -- Human assisted}
-The test can be performed semi-automatically by means of the existing equipment complemented by some dummy loads and, in the same manner the manual performance tests were executed. A computer could control the equipment and compare the results, by the assist of a human that can make the necessary reconnections between the tests. A proposed setup for this is shown in \autoref{fig:test_setup_human_assisted}.
+The test can be performed semi-automatically by means of the existing equipment complemented by some dummy loads, in the same manner the manual performance tests were executed. A computer could control the equipment with GPIB and compare the results. A human needs to make the necessary reconnections between the tests. A proposed setup for this is shown in \autoref{fig:test_setup_human_assisted}.
 
 The main advantage of this alternative is that it would require the least amount of hardware development time. It also doesn't need any extra hardware except from the dummy loads needed to do the verification.
 
 The biggest disadvantage is that it would be very cumbersome to perform and also prone to human error. If the verification list is studied carefully one can minimize it to five reconnections after the initial connections are made, for example in the following order: No load, \SI{2}{\ohm}, \SI{10}{\ohm}, \SI{50}{\ohm} low frequency, \SI{50}{\ohm} high frequency, \SI{1}{\kilo\ohm} high frequency.
 
 \begin{figure}[H]
+    \centering
     %\captionsetup{width=.5\linewidth}
     \includegraphics[width=0.5\textwidth]{test setup human assisted}    
     \caption{The proposed setup for alternative must be connected in different ways by a human during the verification process.}
@@ -136,6 +137,7 @@ To accurately measure Pulse 3a and Pulse 3b, the probes should be attached as cl
 The dummy loads for all pulses, but Pulse 3a and Pulse 3b, will need to be put in a separate enclosure because of the high power dissipation. The proposed dummy loads for pulse 3a and pulse 3b is the external attenuators PAT~50 and PAT~1000. A proposed setup is depicted in \autoref{fig:test_setup_automatic_external}.
 
 \begin{figure}[H]
+    \centering
     %\captionsetup{width=.5\linewidth}
     \includegraphics[width=0.5\textwidth]{test setup automatic external}
     \caption{The proposed setup for alternative 2 is fully automatic, but exposes high voltage connectors between the demultiplexer and the two attenuators, marked with a red line.}
@@ -144,7 +146,7 @@ The dummy loads for all pulses, but Pulse 3a and Pulse 3b, will need to be put i
 
 The advantage of this method is that the verification can be performed fully automatically, except for the initial connection of the test rig. This also uses the commercially created attenuators that are already available.
 
-The disadvantage to this setup is that the fixture needs to be designed, making the development costs greater. The fixture that attaches to the generator will expose high voltage on its measurement connectors, making it a safety hazard.
+The disadvantage to this setup is that the fixture needs to be designed, making the development costs greater. The fixture that attaches to the generator will expose high voltage on its measurement connectors, making it a safety hazard for the test operator.
 
 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
 \subsection{Alternative 3 -- Fully automatic rig with embedded attenuators}
@@ -157,13 +159,14 @@ To design Alternative 3 some utilities needs to be designed, namely:
 \end{itemize}
 
 \begin{figure}[H]
+    \centering
     %\captionsetup{width=.5\linewidth}
     \includegraphics[width=0.5\textwidth]{test setup automatic internal}
     \caption{The proposed setup for alternative 3 have no high voltage connectors exposed during the calibration.}
     \label{fig:test_setup_automatic_internal}
 \end{figure}
 
-The advantages of this, in addition to the advantages of alternative 2, are that there is no longer need for external attenuators and that the connectors will no longer expose high voltage.
+The advantages of this, in addition to the advantages of alternative 2, are that there is no longer need for external attenuators and that the connectors will no longer expose high voltage to the test operator.
 
 The disadvantage of this would be that the embedded attenuators might prove difficult to design. They need to be accurate up to high frequencies, be tolerable to high voltage, dissipate the power necessary and also be electrically safe.
 
@@ -175,7 +178,7 @@ The dummy loads consists of one or more resistors. When determining whether the
 
 Since the pulse generators in most cases can generate a higher voltage than required by the standard, the dummy loads should be designed for the worst case setting on the generator. This mitigates the risk of overloading the dummy load caused human error or an error in the control system.
 
-Three different dummy loads are needed. One \SI{2}{\ohm} load for load dump A and for pulse 2a, one \SI{10}{\ohm} load for pulse 1 in \SI{24}{\volt} systems and one \SI{50}{\ohm} load for pulse 1 in \SI{24}{\volt} systems.
+Three different dummy loads are needed. One \SI{2}{\ohm} load for load dump test A and for test pulse 2a, one \SI{10}{\ohm} load for pulse 1 in \SI{24}{\volt} systems and one \SI{50}{\ohm} load for pulse 1 in \SI{24}{\volt} systems.
 
 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
 \subsection{Components}
@@ -187,7 +190,7 @@ At first the momentary worst case powers and voltages were calculated by hand, u
     \label{eq:dummy_load_peak}
 \end{equation}
 
-Instead of selecting components based on peak power they can be selected based on energy over time. Although, not all manufacturers specify this data in the datasheet. To get the proper values for this project, a simulation was made with LTSpice. The simulated circuit can be seen in \autoref{fig:ltspice-pulse-energy}. There are preconstructed models for all of the relevant pulses, but the parameters are not tweakable. Thus, the pulse offset is removed, the magnitude is normalized and then multiplied by the desired $U_S$ using the behavioural voltage source. The power dissipated in the dummy load is then integrated over time to achieve the energy. The simulated circuit translates to the calculation shown in \autoref{eq:dummy_load_energy}.
+Instead of selecting components based on peak power they can be selected based on energy over time. Although, not all manufacturers specify this data in the datasheet. To get the proper values for this project, a simulation was made with LTSpice. The simulated circuit can be seen in \autoref{fig:ltspice-pulse-energy}. There are preconstructed models for all of the relevant pulses, but the parameters are not tweakable. Thus, the pulse offset is removed, the magnitude is normalized and then multiplied by the desired $U_S$ using the behavioural voltage source component in LTSpice. The power dissipated in the dummy load is then integrated over time to obtain the energy. The simulated circuit translates to the calculation shown in \autoref{eq:dummy_load_energy}.
 
 \begin{equation}
     E_{dummy load} = \int_{t_0}^{t_1}P(t)dt
@@ -213,7 +216,7 @@ Since most of the test pulses exceedes the properties of most resistors availabl
 
 Both the circuit schematic and layout editing of the board were performed in the free EDA, Electronic Design Automation, tool KiCad\footnote{KiCad EDA \url{http://kicad-pcb.org/}}.
 
-Before ordering the PCB, it was printed in 1:1 scale and attached to a piece of card board. The card board was then populated with the components already at hand to ensure that the footprints are correct and that the placement of the components makes sense and does not collide.
+Before ordering the PCB, it was printed in 1:1 scale and attached to a piece of cardboard. The cardboard was then populated with the components already at hand to ensure that the footprints are correct and that the placement of the components make sense and do not collide.
 
 
 
@@ -229,7 +232,7 @@ The chosen implementation requires a fixture with switches and attenuators, whic
     \captionsetup{width=.5\linewidth}
     \centering
     \includegraphics[width=0.5\textwidth]{relay_box}
-    \caption{The multiplexing relay box can couple each of the three inputs through any of the attenuators. It can also connect the external dummy load to the + and - signal.}
+    \caption{The multiplexing relay box can couple each of the three inputs through any of the attenuators. It can also connect the external dummy load to the $+$ and $-$ signal.}
     \label{fig:relay_box}
 \end{figure}
 
@@ -245,13 +248,13 @@ The relays were chosen based on high breakdown voltage between open contacts.
 \subsection{Attenuators}
 The target attenuation was decided to mimic the commercial attenuators, introduced in \autoref{sec:hv-attenuators}, where the \SI{50}{\ohm} attenuator has an attenuation of \SI{54.7}{\deci\bel} and the \SI{1000}{\ohm} attenuator has an attenuation of \SI{60.1}{\deci\bel}.
 
-The two attenuators were implemented as $\Pi$-attenuators. The values for the attenuators were retrieved from an online calculator\footnote{$\Pi$ attenuator calculator \url{https://chemandy.com/calculators/matching-pi-attenuator-calculator.htm}}, and then simulated in LTSpice to verify the values.
+The two attenuators were implemented as $\Pi$-attenuators. The resistor values for the attenuators were retrieved from an online calculator\footnote{$\Pi$ attenuator calculator \url{https://chemandy.com/calculators/matching-pi-attenuator-calculator.htm}}, and then simulated in LTSpice to verify the resulting properties.
 
-By dividing the attenuators into two $\Pi$-networks, the series resistance required is lower compared to realizing them in a single $\Pi$-link. This is desirable because the parasitic capacitance, which is dependent of the resistor package and not the resistance value, will influence a high value resistor at lower frequencies than it would on a low value resistor, as explained in \autoref{sec:theory:resistors_at_high_frequencies}.
+By dividing the attenuators into two $\Pi$-networks, the series resistance required is lower compared to realizing them in a single $\Pi$-network. This is desirable because the parasitic capacitance, which is dependent of the resistor package and not the resistance value, will influence a high value resistor more at lower frequencies than it would on a low value resistor, as explained in \autoref{sec:theory:resistors_at_high_frequencies}.
 
-When the ideal resistor values had been achieved, the power over time and maximum voltage for each resistor was retrieved by simulation in a similar way as for the dummy load described in \autoref{sec:dummy_load:components}. Based on this, the minimum number of discrete resistors needed to withstand the pulse energy was calculated. The minimum number of series resistors to withstand the maximum pulse voltage was also retrived from the simulation.
+When the ideal resistor values had been obtained, the power over time and maximum voltage for each resistor was obtained by simulation in a similar way as for the dummy load described in \autoref{sec:dummy_load:components}. Based on this, the minimum number of discrete resistors needed to withstand the pulse energy was calculated. The minimum number of series resistors to withstand the maximum pulse voltage was also obtained from the simulation.
 
-With the minimum number of discrete resistors needed for each ideal resistor known, a constellation of available resistor values was constructed to approximate the nominal value with as few resistors as possible.
+With the minimum number of discrete resistors needed for each ideal resistor known, a constellation of available resistor values was constructed to approximate the nominal value with as few resistors as possible. The circuits for the two attenuators are presented in \autoref{sec:result-attenuators}.
 
 When the number of resistors and their constellations was decided, all of the discrete ideal resistors were replaced with non-ideal models in the simulation software. Each lead inductance was set to \SI{1}{\nano\henry}, the internal inductance was set to \SI{0.1}{\nano\henry} and the internal capacitance was set to \SI{1}{\pico\farad}. Then the attenuators were checked in frequency domain, as well as how the pulses were affected in time domain. If the required \SI{400}{\mega\hertz} bandwidth could not be achieved, frequency compensation with capacitors was attempted.
 
@@ -262,7 +265,7 @@ A PCB was designed for the attenuators and the switches. This gives good control
 
 The design process followed the same methods as for the dummy load PCB. But because of the higher voltages some special considerations had to be made.
 
-The measurement connectors accessible on the outside of the encapsulation must safe at all times. This involves keeping a minimum creepage distance of \SI{6}{\milli\meter} to any trace that carry a high voltage, according to the regulations in EN~60664\nd1 \cite{en_60664_1}.
+The measurement connectors accessible on the outside of the encapsulation must be electrically safe at all times. This involves keeping a minimum creepage distance of \SI{6}{\milli\meter} to any trace that carry a high voltage, according to the regulations in EN~60664\nd1 \cite{en_60664_1}.
 
 The EDA tool has functionality for design rule checking, DRC, but there are some limitations in this function that inhibit its use in this case. The DRC in KiCad only allows to set the clearance for a specified net to all other nets. In this case it is only desired to restrict the clearance between the high voltage traces to the traces that must be considered safe. It is allowed for one high voltage trace to be close to another high voltage trace, it is only the functional isolation requirement of \SI{3}{\milli\meter} that applies here. The output signal and the output ground can also be close to each other, since both are considered safe.
 
@@ -280,19 +283,19 @@ The layout was printed in 1:1 scale to verify the layout in the same way as for
 
 When the PCB was delivered, it was visually inspected before assembling. Some modifications were required to fulfill the clearance criteria, these were made using a rotary multitool to machine away the undesired part of the traces.
 
-No compensation of the attenuators were made during the work of this thesis, since this require more time.
+No compensation of the attenuators were made during the work of this thesis, since this requires more time.
 
 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
 \subsection{Measurements}
-Since the relay card will be used in measuring pulses with short rise times, it is of importance to know that it does not distort the signal too much. It is desired to measure the magnitude response in the frequency domain, as well as the test pulse in time domain.
+Since the relay card will be used for measuring pulses with short rise times, it is of importance to know that it does not distort the signal. It is desired to measure the magnitude response in the frequency domain, as well as the test pulse in time domain.
 
-To measure the magnitude response, an S21 measurement was performed using the ZVL network analyzer. A fixture was made to mimic the front panel of the CNA~200 to allow for a representative connection of the relay card. The setup can be seen in \autoref{fig:network_analyzing}. This setup proved to be unstable at first, as moving the coaxial wires and the grounding wire greatly affected the results for the higher frequencies. Because of the unstable results early in the measuring process, a modification was made to shorten the ground connection by attaching a braid as close as the attenuator grounds as possible and then grounding it directly to the fixture case, as depicted in \autoref{fig:ground_braid}. All subsequent measurements were performed with this modification.
+To measure the magnitude response, an $S_{21}$ measurement was performed using the ZVL network analyzer. A fixture was made to mimic the front panel of the CNA~200 to allow for a representative connection of the relay card. The setup can be seen in \autoref{fig:network_analyzing}. This setup proved to be unstable at first, as moving the coaxial wires and the grounding wire greatly affected the results for the higher frequencies. Because of the unstable results early in the measuring process, a modification was made to shorten the ground connection by attaching a braid as close to the attenuator grounds as possible and then grounding it directly to the fixture case, as depicted in \autoref{fig:ground_braid}. All subsequent measurements were performed with this modification.
 
-The signal was measured for each output terminal through each of the attenuators to get the magnitude response for the intended use, \autoref{fig:relay_box_other_open} shows this for the + terminal. To see how well the design suppresses unconnected signals, the magnitude response was also measured when the signal was disconnected completely, i.e. all the relays in the fixture were opened as s\autoref{fig:relay_box_all_open}. In addition to this, the magnitude response was also measured with all but the relays on the current terminal closed, seen in \autoref{fig:relay_box_other_closed}, to see if there was any overhearing on the circuit board from the other terminals and the traces after the relays. The results were saved both as an image and as raw data in the form of complex numbers in a CSV file to allow for further analysis and plotting.
+The signal was measured for each output terminal through each of the attenuators to get the magnitude response for the intended use, \autoref{fig:relay_box_other_open} shows this for the + terminal. To see how well the design suppresses unconnected signals, the magnitude response was also measured when the signal was disconnected completely, i.e. all the relays in the fixture were opened as depicted in \autoref{fig:relay_box_all_open}. In addition to this, the magnitude response was also measured with all but the relays on the current terminal closed, seen in \autoref{fig:relay_box_other_closed}, to see if there was any overhearing on the circuit board from the other terminals and the traces after the relays. The results were saved both as an image and as raw data in the form of complex numbers in a CSV\nd{}file to allow for further analysis and plotting.
 
 A single relay was also measured using the network analyzer to get a perception of its high frequency properties. The setup was made by soldering coaxial cable directly to the relay, with as short connecting wires as possible to prevent any influence on the result from the wires. The setup can be seen in \autoref{fig:relay-setup}.
 
-To measure the test pulses through the attenuators, the switching fixture was connected to the CNA~200 and the pulses were measured on the intended connectors using an oscilloscope, as seen in \autoref{fig:relay_card_measurement_time}. The results were saved both as an image and as data points in a CVS file, for further analysis.
+To measure the test pulses through the attenuators, the switching fixture was connected to the CNA~200 and the pulses were measured on the intended connectors using an oscilloscope, as seen in \autoref{fig:relay_card_measurement_time}. The results were saved both as an image and as data points in a CSV\nd{}file, for further analysis.
 
 For comparison, the commercial attenuators were also measured in frequency domain with the ZVL and in time domain using the oscilloscope.
 
@@ -334,7 +337,7 @@ For comparison, the commercial attenuators were also measured in frequency domai
 	\end{subfigure}\hfill
 	\begin{subfigure}[t]{0.3\textwidth}
 		\includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{relay_box_all_open}
-		\caption{The isolation of the signal from the cominging terminals to the output of the attenuator.}
+		\caption{The isolation of the signal from the incoming terminals to the output of the attenuator.}
 		\label{fig:relay_box_all_open}
 	\end{subfigure}\hfill
 	\begin{subfigure}[t]{0.3\textwidth}
@@ -342,6 +345,6 @@ For comparison, the commercial attenuators were also measured in frequency domai
 		\caption{The isolation of the signal from all other signal paths connected to the output of the attenuator.}
 		\label{fig:relay_box_other_closed}
 	\end{subfigure}
-	\caption{The different scenarios that were measured in frequency domain for the + terminal to the \SI{50}{\ohm} attenuator. Corresponding measurements were made for the - and the PE terminal as well as for the \SI{1000}{\ohm} attenuator.}
+	\caption{The different scenarios that were measured in frequency domain for the $+$ terminal to the \SI{50}{\ohm} attenuator. Corresponding measurements were made for the $-$ and the PE terminal as well as for the \SI{1000}{\ohm} attenuator.}
 \end{figure}
 

+ 4 - 1
rapport/results.tex

@@ -36,7 +36,7 @@ This chapter presents the results achieved using the methods described in \autor
 
 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
 \section{Prestudy}
-Since not much was known about the project at this time, it was difficult to find relevant papers on the topic of the standards.  Most of the literature was found during the project as new problems was found along the way.
+Since not much was known about the project at this time, it was difficult to find relevant papers on the topic of the standards. Most of the literature was found during the project to solve problems as they were discovered.
 
 Since the test equipment was mostly in line with the new standards, the first project path was chosen. There was not enough time available to investigate any of the extra tasks as intended.
 
@@ -385,6 +385,7 @@ The Panasonic's LF-G relays were chosen as switching elements as they have a hig
 
 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
 \subsection{Attenuators}
+\label{sec:result-attenuators}
 The \SI{54.7}{\deci\bel} attenuator was divided into two \SI{27.35}{\deci\bel} $\Pi$ attenuator links. The values obtained from the online calculator was \SI{54.48}{\ohm} as the parallel resistors and \SI{581.62}{\ohm} as the series resistor. Then the closest values for the resistors was chosen to \SI{54.67}{\ohm} as parallel resistors and \SI{560}{\ohm} as series resistors. The final attenuation was \SI{53.76}{\deci\bel} for the two links according to the simulation, as seen in \autoref{fig:ltspice-54db-attenuator}. The design was realized as seen in \autoref{fig:ltspice-54db-attenuator-comp}, based on the maximum voltages and powers. Capacitors were placed in the schematic to allow for phase compensation.
 
 Since the uncompensated circuit had its \SI{3}{\deci\bel} limit at only \SI{190}{\mega\hertz}, as seen in \autoref{fig:ltspice-54db-attenuator-freq}, the circuit had to be compensated. The results after the compensation can be seen in \autoref{fig:ltspice-54db-attenuator-freq-comp} where the new \SI{3}{\deci\bel} limit is instead at \SI{1.7}{\giga\hertz}. The values used for compensating the circuit was \SI{130}{\pico\farad} for the first parallel resistance and \SI{10}{\pico\farad} for the second parallel link as seen in \autoref{fig:ltspice-54db-attenuator-comp}.
@@ -421,6 +422,7 @@ Since the uncompensated circuit had its \SI{3}{\deci\bel} limit at only \SI{190}
 	\end{subfigure}
 	
 	\caption{The \SI{50}{\ohm} attenuator simulated.}
+	\label{fig:50-ohm-result}
 \end{figure}
 
 
@@ -460,6 +462,7 @@ Since the uncompensated circuit had its \SI{3}{\deci\bel} limit at only \SI{130}
 	\end{subfigure}
 	
 	\caption{The \SI{1000}{\ohm} attenuator simulated.}
+	\label{fig:1k-ohm-result}
 \end{figure}
 
 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%

+ 60 - 59
rapport/theory.tex

@@ -49,7 +49,7 @@ A standard is developed and maintained by a Technical Committee, TC. The TC cons
 
 The naming convention used for ISO standards is in the format \emph{number-part:year}, where the \emph{number} is the identifier to the unique ISO standard, \emph{part} denotes the part of the standard if it is divided into several parts and \emph{year} is the publishing year. For example; the name \emph{ISO~7637-2:2011} refers to part 2 of the ISO~7637 standard published in 2011, whilst \emph{ISO~7637-2:2004} would refer to an earlier version of the exact same document published in 2004.
 
-To get hold of a copy of a standard, one need to buy it from ISO store or from a national ISO member. \cite{site:iso_shopping_faqs}
+The ISO standards can be obtained from ISO's web store or from a national ISO member. \cite{site:iso_shopping_faqs}
 
 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
 \section{ISO~7637 and ISO~16750}
@@ -57,7 +57,7 @@ To get hold of a copy of a standard, one need to buy it from ISO store or from a
 \textbf{The ISO~7637 standard}, \emph{Road vehicles — Electrical disturbances from
 conduction and coupling}, concerns the electrical environment in road vehicles. The standard consists of four parts, as of August 2019.
 
-Part 1, \emph{Definitions and general considerations}, defines some abbreviations and technical terms that are used throughout the standard. It also intended use of the standard. \cite{iso_7637_1}
+Part 1, \emph{Definitions and general considerations}, define abbreviations and technical terms that are used throughout the standard. It also intended use of the standard. \cite{iso_7637_1}
 
 Part 2, \emph{Electrical transient conduction along supply lines only}, defines the test procedures related to disturbances that are carried along the supply lines of a product. Both emission, disturbances created by the DUT, and immunity, the DUT's capability to withstand disturbances, are covered. This part defines the test pulses that are of interest for this project, and the verification of them. \cite{iso_7637_2}
 
@@ -73,20 +73,20 @@ The ISO~16750, \emph{Road vehicles -- Environmental conditions and testing for e
 
 All test pulses defined in ISO~7637 and ISO~16750 are supposed to simulate events that can occur in a real vehicle's electrical environment, that equipment must be able to withstand. The properties of these test pulses are well defined, to allow for unified testing regardless of which test lab that performs the test. In the real world, however, the disturbances might of course differ from the test pulses since a real case environment is not controlled. \cite{iso_7637_2,iso_16750_2, comparison_iso_7637_real_world}
 
-The test pulses of interest defined in ISO~7637 are denoted \emph{Test pulse 1}, \emph{Test pulse 2a}, \emph{Test pulse 3a} and \emph{Test pulse 3b}. The test pulse of interest defined in ISO~16750 is denoted \emph{Load dump Test A}. There are more pulses and tests defined in these standards, but those are not in the scope of this project.
+The test pulses of interest defined in ISO~7637 are denoted \emph{test pulse 1}, \emph{test pulse 2a}, \emph{test pulse 3a} and \emph{test pulse 3b}. The test pulse of interest defined in ISO~16750 is denoted \emph{load dump test A}. There are more pulses and tests defined in these standards, but those are not in the scope of this project.
 
 The general characteristics in common for all pulses are the DC voltage $U_A$, the surge voltage $U_s$, the rise time $t_r$, the pulse duration $t_d$ and the internal resistance $R_i$. The property \emph{internal resistance} is only in series with the generated pulse, not in series with the DC power source. For pulses that are supposed to be applied several times, $t_1$ usually denotes the time between the start of two consecutive pulses. The timings are illustrated in  \autoref{fig:doubleexp}.
 
 \begin{figure}[H]
 	\centering
-	\begin{subfigure}[t]{0.45\textwidth}
+	\begin{subfigure}[t]{0.6\textwidth}
 	    \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{doubleexpfunc}
 	    \caption{The surge voltage $U_S$ is the puse maximum voltage disregarding the offset voltage $U_A$. The rise $t_r$ time is defined as the time elapsed from 0.1 to 0.9 times the surge voltage on the rising edge of the pulse. The duration $t_d$  is defined as the time from 0.1 times the maximum voltage on the rising edge, back to the same level of the falling edge.}
    	    \label{fig:doubleexp}
 	\end{subfigure}\hfill
 	\begin{subfigure}[t]{0.45\textwidth}
 	    \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{doubleexpfuncrep}    
-	    \caption{The repetition time is defined as the time between two adjacent rising edges.}
+	    \caption{The repetition time $t_1$ is defined as the time between two adjacent rising edges.}
    	    \label{fig:doubleexprep}
 	\end{subfigure}
 	\caption{The common properties of the pulses, as defined by ISO~7637.}
@@ -103,15 +103,14 @@ In the standard there are two additional timings associated to this pulse, $t_2$
 \begin{figure}[H]
     %\captionsetup{width=.5\linewidth}
     \centering
-    \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{pulse1}    
+    \includegraphics[width=0.6\textwidth]{pulse1}    
     \caption{Illustration of test pulse 1.}
     \label{fig:pulse1}
 \end{figure}
-
 \begin{table}[H]
     \centering
     \caption{Parameter values for pulse 1}
-    \begin{tabularx}{0.7\textwidth}{|X|c|c|}
+    \begin{tabularx}{0.45\textwidth}{|X|c|c|}
         \hline
         \textbf{Parameter}	&\textbf{\SI{12}{\volt} system}	&\textbf{\SI{24}{\volt} system}	\\
         \hline
@@ -142,7 +141,7 @@ This pulse simulates the event of a load, parallel to the DUT, being disconnecte
 \begin{figure}[H]
     %\captionsetup{width=.5\linewidth}
     \centering
-    \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{pulse2a}    
+    \includegraphics[width=0.6\textwidth]{pulse2a}    
     \caption{Illustration of test pulse 2a.}
     \label{fig:pulse2a}
 \end{figure}
@@ -172,19 +171,19 @@ This pulse simulates the event of a load, parallel to the DUT, being disconnecte
 
 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
 \subsection{Test pulse 3a and 3b}
-Test pulse 3a and 3b simulates transients ``which occur as a result of the switching process'' as stated in the standard \cite{iso_7637_2}. The formulation is not very clear, but is interperted and explained by Frazier and Alles \cite{comparison_iso_7637_real_world} to be the result of a mechanical switch breaking an inductive load. These transients are very short, compared to the other pulses, and the repetition time is very short. The pulses are sent in bursts, grouping a number of pulses together and separating groups by a fixed time.
+Test pulse 3a and 3b simulate transients ``which occur as a result of the switching process'' as stated in the standard \cite{iso_7637_2}. The formulation is not very clear, but is interpreted and explained by Frazier and Alles \cite{comparison_iso_7637_real_world} to be the result of a mechanical switch breaking an inductive load. These transients are very short, compared to the other pulses, and the repetition time is very short. The pulses are sent in bursts, grouping a number of pulses together and separating groups by a fixed time.
 
 These pulses contain high frequency components, up to 100~MHz, and special care must be taken when running tests with them as well as when verifying them.
 
 
 \begin{figure}[H]
 	\centering
-	\begin{subfigure}[t]{0.45\textwidth}
+	\begin{subfigure}[t]{0.3\textwidth}
 	    \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{pulse3a}
 	    \caption{Pulse 3a}
    	    \label{fig:pulse3a}
 	\end{subfigure}\hfill
-	\begin{subfigure}[t]{0.45\textwidth}
+	\begin{subfigure}[t]{0.3\textwidth}
 	    \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{pulse3b}    
 	    \caption{Pulse 3b}
    	    \label{fig:pulse3b}
@@ -224,16 +223,16 @@ These pulses contain high frequency components, up to 100~MHz, and special care
 
 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
 \subsection{Load dump Test A}
-The Load dump Test A simulates the event of disconnecting a battery that is charged by the vehicles alternator, the current that the alternator is driving will give rise to a long voltage transient.
+The load dump test A simulates the event of disconnecting a battery that is charged by the vehicles alternator, the current that the alternator is driving will give rise to a long voltage transient.
 
 This pulse has the longest duration, $t_d$, of all the test pulses. It also has the lowest internal resistance. These properties makes it capable of transferring high energies into a low impedance DUT or dummy load.
 
-Prior to 2011, the Load dump Test A was part of the ISO~7637-2 standard under the name \emph{Test pulse 5a}. The surge voltage $U_s$ was in the older standard, \mbox{ISO~7637-2:2004}, defined as the voltage between the DC offset voltage $U_A$ and the maximum voltage. In the newer standard, \mbox{ISO~16750-2:2012}, $U_s$ is defined as the absolute peak voltage. Only the former definition is used in this paper, $U_s = \hat{U} - U_A$.
+Prior to 2011, the load dump test A was part of the ISO~7637-2 standard under the name \emph{test pulse 5a}. The surge voltage $U_s$ was in the older standard, \mbox{ISO~7637-2:2004}, defined as the voltage between the DC offset voltage $U_A$ and the maximum voltage. In the newer standard, \mbox{ISO~16750-2:2012}, $U_s$ is defined as the absolute peak voltage. Only the former definition is used in this paper, $U_s = \hat{U} - U_A$.
 
 \begin{figure}[H]
     %\captionsetup{width=.5\linewidth}
     \centering
-    \includegraphics[width=\textwidth]{load dump a}
+    \includegraphics[width=0.6\textwidth]{load dump a}
     \caption{Illustration of load dump Test A. Note the different definition of $U_S$ compared to the other pulses.}
     \label{fig:loadDumpTestA}
 \end{figure}
@@ -263,7 +262,7 @@ Prior to 2011, the Load dump Test A was part of the ISO~7637-2 standard under th
 
 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
 \subsection{Application of test pulses}
-During a test, the nominal voltage is first applied between the plus and minus terminal of the DUT's power supply input by the test equipment. Then a series of test pulses are applied between the same terminals. The pulses are repeated at specified intervals, $t_1$, as depicted in \autoref{fig:doubleexprep}.
+During a test, the nominal voltage is first applied between the plus and minus terminal of the DUT's power supply input by the test equipment. Then a series of test pulses are applied between the same terminals. The pulses are repeated at specified intervals, $t_1$, as depicted in \mbox{\autoref{fig:doubleexprep}}.
 
 An example of how a test pulse can be applied by the test equipment is depicted in \autoref{fig:test_equipment_setup}.
 
@@ -277,37 +276,38 @@ An example of how a test pulse can be applied by the test equipment is depicted
 
 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
 \subsection{Verification}
-The test pulses are to be verified before they are applied to the DUT. The voltage levels and the timings are to be measured both without any load, and with a matched load, $R_L$ = $R_i$, attached. The standard omits the rise time constraint when the load is attached, except for pulse 3a and 3b. \cite{iso_7637_2}
+\label{sec:theory:verification}
+The test pulses are to be verified before they are applied to the DUT. The voltage levels and the timings measured both without load, and with a dummy load $R_L$ which is matched to the generators internal resistance $R_i$. The standard omits the rise time constraint when the dummy load is attached, except for pulse 3a and 3b. \cite{iso_7637_2}
 
 The verification is to be conducted with $U_A$ set to 0. There is, however, a proposal to set $U_A$ equal to the nominal voltage during the verification process, as the behaviour of the pulse generators has proven differ in this case \cite{iso_7637_5}. In this project $U_A = 0$ will be used.
 
 The limits, and tolerances, for the pulses are summarised in \autoref{tab:verification-list}. The matched loads are to be within 1\% of the nominal value.
 
-The instruments used for measuring the pulses must have at least \SI{400}{\mega\hertz}, since pulse 3a and 3b contains frequency components of up to \SI{200}{\mega\hertz}.
+The instruments used for measuring the pulses must have at least \SI{400}{\mega\hertz}, since pulse 3a and 3b contains frequency components of up to \SI{200}{\mega\hertz}. The measurement in open state for pulse 3a and 3b is a compromise, since a passive attenuator that does not load the input would be impossible to make, and was made as a 1000-ohm attenuator instead. This is how a similar generator is tested in another standard, the burst test \todo[Ta reda på hur det kommer sig att vi kör med 1k istället för oändligt].
 
 \begin{table}[H]
-    \caption{These are all of the verifications that needs to be made before each use of the equipment, along with the limits for each case.}
+    \caption{These are all of the verifications that needs to be made before each use of the equipment, along with the limits specified in ISO~7637-2.}
 \begin{adjustbox}{width=\columnwidth,center}
     %\centering
     \begin{tabular}{|l|r|r|r|r|} 
         \hline
          & & \multicolumn{3}{c|}{Limits}\\
-        Pulse & Match resistor & $U_S$ & $t_d$ & $t_r$ \\
-        \hline
-        Pulse 1, 12 V, Open        &              & \SIrange{-110}{ -90}{\volt} & \SIrange{1.6}{2.4}{\milli\second} & \SIrange{0.5}{  1}{\micro\second} \\
-        Pulse 1, 12 V, Matched     & 10 \si{\ohm} & \SIrange{-110}{ -90}{\volt} & \SIrange{1.6}{2.4}{\milli\second} & \SIrange{0.5}{  1}{\micro\second} \\
-        Pulse 1, 24 V, Open        &              & \SIrange{-660}{-540}{\volt} & \SIrange{0.8}{1.2}{\milli\second} & \SIrange{1.5}{  3}{\micro\second} \\
-        Pulse 1, 24 V, Matched     & 50 \si{\ohm} & \SIrange{-660}{-540}{\volt} & \SIrange{0.8}{1.2}{\milli\second} & \SIrange{1.5}{  3}{\micro\second} \\
-        Pulse 2a, Open             &              & \SIrange{67.5}{82.5}{\volt} & \SIrange{ 40}{ 60}{\micro\second} & \SIrange{0.5}{  1}{\micro\second} \\
-        Pulse 2a, Matched          &  2 \si{\ohm} & \SIrange{67.5}{82.5}{\volt} & \SIrange{ 40}{ 60}{\micro\second} & \SIrange{0.5}{  1}{\micro\second} \\
-        Pulse 3a, Open (1k)        &              & \SIrange{-220}{-180}{\volt} & \SIrange{105}{195}{\nano\second}  & \SIrange{3.5}{6.5}{\nano\second}  \\
-        Pulse 3a, Match            & 50 \si{\ohm} & \SIrange{-120}{ -80}{\volt} & \SIrange{105}{195}{\nano\second}  & \SIrange{3.5}{6.5}{\nano\second}  \\
-        Pulse 3b, Open (1k)        &              & \SIrange{ 180}{ 220}{\volt} & \SIrange{105}{195}{\nano\second}  & \SIrange{3.5}{6.5}{\nano\second}  \\
-        Pulse 3b, Match            & 50 \si{\ohm} & \SIrange{  80}{ 120}{\volt} & \SIrange{105}{195}{\nano\second}  & \SIrange{3.5}{6.5}{\nano\second}  \\
-        Load dump A, 12 V, Open    &              & \SIrange{  90}{ 110}{\volt} & \SIrange{320}{480}{\milli\second} & \SIrange{  5}{ 10}{\milli\second} \\
-        Load dump A, 12 V, Matched &  2 \si{\ohm} & \SIrange{  90}{ 110}{\volt} & \SIrange{320}{480}{\milli\second} & \SIrange{  5}{ 10}{\milli\second} \\
-        Load dump A, 24 V, Open    &              & \SIrange{ 180}{ 220}{\volt} & \SIrange{280}{420}{\milli\second} & \SIrange{  5}{ 10}{\milli\second} \\
-        Load dump A, 24 V, Matched &  2 \si{\ohm} & \SIrange{ 180}{ 220}{\volt} & \SIrange{280}{420}{\milli\second} & \SIrange{  5}{ 10}{\milli\second} \\
+        Test pulse & Match resistor & $U_S$ & $t_d$ & $t_r$ \\
+        \hline
+        Test pulse 1, 12 V, Open        &              & \SIrange{-110}{ -90}{\volt} & \SIrange{1.6}{2.4}{\milli\second} & \SIrange{0.5}{  1}{\micro\second} \\
+        Test pulse 1, 12 V, Matched     & 10 \si{\ohm} & \SIrange{ -60}{ -40}{\volt} & \SIrange{1.6}{2.4}{\milli\second} & N/A \\
+        Test pulse 1, 24 V, Open        &              & \SIrange{-660}{-540}{\volt} & \SIrange{0.8}{1.2}{\milli\second} & \SIrange{1.5}{  3}{\micro\second} \\
+        Test pulse 1, 24 V, Matched     & 50 \si{\ohm} & \SIrange{-360}{-240}{\volt} & \SIrange{0.8}{1.2}{\milli\second} & N/A \\
+        Test pulse 2a, Open             &              & \SIrange{67.5}{82.5}{\volt} & \SIrange{ 40}{ 60}{\micro\second} & \SIrange{0.5}{  1}{\micro\second} \\
+        Test pulse 2a, Matched          &  2 \si{\ohm} & \SIrange{  45}{  30}{\volt} & \SIrange{ 40}{ 60}{\micro\second} & \SIrange{0.5}{  1}{\micro\second} \\
+        Test pulse 3a, Open (1k)        &              & \SIrange{-220}{-180}{\volt} & \SIrange{105}{195}{\nano\second}  & \SIrange{3.5}{6.5}{\nano\second}  \\
+        Test pulse 3a, Match            & 50 \si{\ohm} & \SIrange{-120}{ -80}{\volt} & \SIrange{105}{195}{\nano\second}  & \SIrange{3.5}{6.5}{\nano\second}  \\
+        Test pulse 3b, Open (1k)        &              & \SIrange{ 180}{ 220}{\volt} & \SIrange{105}{195}{\nano\second}  & \SIrange{3.5}{6.5}{\nano\second}  \\
+        Test pulse 3b, Match            & 50 \si{\ohm} & \SIrange{  80}{ 120}{\volt} & \SIrange{105}{195}{\nano\second}  & \SIrange{3.5}{6.5}{\nano\second}  \\
+        Load dump test A, 12 V, Open    &              & \SIrange{  90}{ 110}{\volt} & \SIrange{320}{480}{\milli\second} & \SIrange{  5}{ 10}{\milli\second} \\
+        Load dump test A, 12 V, Matched &  2 \si{\ohm} & \SIrange{  40}{  60}{\volt} & \SIrange{160}{240}{\milli\second} & N/A \\
+        Load dump test A, 24 V, Open    &              & \SIrange{ 180}{ 220}{\volt} & \SIrange{280}{420}{\milli\second} & \SIrange{  5}{ 10}{\milli\second} \\
+        Load dump test A, 24 V, Matched &  2 \si{\ohm} & \SIrange{  80}{ 120}{\volt} & \SIrange{140}{210}{\milli\second} & N/A \\
         \hline
     \end{tabular}
 \end{adjustbox}
@@ -318,9 +318,10 @@ The instruments used for measuring the pulses must have at least \SI{400}{\mega\
 \section{Resistors at high frequencies}
 \label{sec:theory:resistors_at_high_frequencies}
 
-When working with resistors at high frequencies, one must consider the parasitc properties of the resistor. Vishay presents a model which consists of the resistance $R$, internal inductance $L$, internal capacitance $C$, external lead inductance $L_C$ and external ground capacitance $C_G$. Since the external ground capacitance is very small in comparison to the other parasitics, it has been neglected in this thesis. The model used for the simulations is depicted in \autoref{fig:nonIdealResistor}, with the values $L = \SI{0.1}{\nano\henry}$, $C = \SI{1}{\pico\farad}$ and $L_C = \SI{1}{\nano\henry}$. This is a bit higher than the values in Vishays paper, but those are also for smaller packages. \cite{vishay_hf_resistor} An approximation of the combined inductance of more than \SI{1}{\nano\henry} for the 1206 package is also in line with the values in a technical information note from AVX for capacitors, the package lead inductance should be similar for capacitors and resistors\cite{avx_cap_parasitic}.
+When working with resistors at high frequencies, one must consider the parasitc properties of the resistor. Vishay presents a model which consists of the resistance $R$, internal inductance $L$, internal capacitance $C$, external lead inductance $L_C$ and external ground capacitance $C_G$. \cite{vishay_hf_resistor} Since the external ground capacitance is very small in comparison to the other parasitics, it has been neglected in this thesis. The model used for the simulations is depicted in \autoref{fig:nonIdealResistor}, with the values $L = \SI{0.1}{\nano\henry}$, $C = \SI{1}{\pico\farad}$ and $L_C = \SI{1}{\nano\henry}$. This is a bit higher than the values in Vishays paper, but those are also for smaller packages. An approximation of the combined inductance of more than \SI{1}{\nano\henry} for the 1206 SMD package is also in line with the values in a technical information note from AVX for capacitors, the package lead inductance should be similar for capacitors and resistors. \cite{avx_cap_parasitic}
 
 \begin{figure}[H]
+    \centering
     \includegraphics[width=0.5\textwidth]{nonIdealResistor}    
     \caption{At high frequencies a resistors parasitic inductance and capacitance will affect the behavior of the circuit. This is the model used in this thesis when simulating circuits.}
     \label{fig:nonIdealResistor}
@@ -333,10 +334,11 @@ There are several measurement methods needed during the project. To verify the t
 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
 \subsection{Resistance}
 \label{sec:measurement:resistance}
-To measure resistance, a current is fed through the resistor and the resulting voltage is measured to calculate the resistance using ohms law. This is typically carried out using a multimeter and two probe wires connecting to each terminal of the resistor. When measuring very low valued resistors, however, the resistance in the probe wires can be significant in relation to the resistor measured and will affect the accuracy. One way of overcoming this is to perform a 4-wire measurement using a so called \emph{Kelvin connection}. In this method the current that is fed through the resistor using one pair of wire, and the resulting voltage is measured at the desired point using another pair according to \autoref{fig:kelvin_measurement}.\cite{theCircuitDesignersCompanion}
+Resistance can be determined by applying a known voltage and measure the resulting current or, the other way around, applying a known current and measure the resulting voltage. The resistance is then calculated from these values using Ohm's law. This is typically done using a multimeter and two probe wires to connect each terminal of the resistor. When measuring very low valued resistors, however, the resistance in the probe wires can be significant in relation to the resistor measured and will affect the accuracy. One way of overcoming this is to perform a 4-wire measurement using a so called \emph{Kelvin connection}. In this method the current that is fed through the resistor using one pair of wire, and the resulting voltage is measured at the desired point using another pair according to \autoref{fig:kelvin_measurement}.\cite{theCircuitDesignersCompanion}
 
 \begin{figure}[H]
     %\captionsetup{width=.5\linewidth}
+    \centering
     \includegraphics[width=0.5\textwidth]{kelvin_measurement}    
     \caption{When measuring a low value resistor, the \emph{Kelvin connection} can be used to determine the resistance at the point where the voltmeter is connected without the resistance in the probe leads affecting the result.}
     \label{fig:kelvin_measurement}
@@ -344,7 +346,7 @@ To measure resistance, a current is fed through the resistor and the resulting v
 
 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
 \subsection{Oscilloscopes, bandwidth, rise time and probes}
-When using an oscilloscope to measure voltage over time, there are several limiting factors to how fast signals one can measure. The oscilloscope itself has a specified bandwidth, as do the probe and any attenuators used. All of these combined determine how short rise times that can be measured accurately. The rise time of the measured will be affected by these properties and the rise time displayed on the oscilloscope screen will be approximately according to \autoref{equ:riseComposite}, where $T_N$ is the \SIrange{10}{90}{\percent} rise time limit for each part in the chain. \cite{highSpeedDigitalDesign}
+When using an oscilloscope to measure voltage over time, there are several limiting factors to how fast signals one can measure. The oscilloscope itself has a specified bandwidth, as do the probe and any attenuators used. All of these combined determine how short rise times that can be measured accurately. The rise time of the measured signal will be affected by these properties and the rise time displayed on the oscilloscope screen will be approximately according to \autoref{equ:riseComposite}, where $T_N$ is the \SIrange{10}{90}{\percent} rise time limit for each part in the chain. \cite{highSpeedDigitalDesign}
 
 \begin{equation}
 \label{equ:riseComposite}
@@ -355,7 +357,7 @@ Since \autoref{equ:riseComposite} is based on the rise time limitation but the s
 
 \begin{equation}
 \label{equ:bwToRise}
-T_{10-90} = \frac{0.338}{F_{ \SI{3}{\deci\bel}}}
+T_{10-90} = \frac{0.338}{F_{ \SI{3}{\deci\bel}}}\si{\second}
 \end{equation}
 
 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
@@ -364,25 +366,25 @@ The data points from the measurement must be processed and evaluated to determin
 
 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
 \subsection{Mathematical description}
-All of the test pulses applied to the vehicle equipment can individually be described mathematically by variations of the double exponential function shown in \autoref{eq:doubleexp}. The properties of interest, the ones which are specified in the standards, are the surge voltage $ U_s $, the rise time $ t_r $, the duration $ t_d $ and the repetition time $ t_1 $. \cite{iso_7637_2}
+All test pulses applied to the vehicle equipment can individually be described mathematically by variations of the double exponential function shown in \autoref{eq:doubleexp}. The properties of interest, the ones which are specified in the standards, are the surge voltage $ U_s $, the rise time $ t_r $, the duration $ t_d $ and the repetition time $ t_1 $. \cite{iso_7637_2}
 
 \begin{equation}
     u(t)=k(e^{\alpha t} - e^{\beta t}) + U_{A}
     \label{eq:doubleexp}
 \end{equation}
 
-It is not in the scope of this report to actually fit this function to the measured pulse, and further analyze it.
+It is not in the scope of this report to actually fit this function to the measured pulses, and further analyze it.
 
 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
 \section{Instrumentation and control}
-The following chapter describes the different instruments that were used, and their control interfaces.
+The following chapter describes the different instruments that were used, and their control interfaces. Some of these are equipped with GPIB, General Purpose Interface Bus, which is a parallel bus used for controlling instruments.
 
 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
 \subsection{Tektronix TDS7104 Oscilloscope}
-The oscilloscope available for this project is a Tektronix TDS7104, with specifications as seen in \autoref{tab:tds7104}. It has GPIB interface and TekVISA GPIB, an API for sending GPIB commands over ethernet, available for remote control. \footnote{\url{https://www.tek.com/datasheet/tds7000-series}}
+The oscilloscope available for this project is a Tektronix TDS7104\footnote{\url{https://www.tek.com/datasheet/tds7000-series}}, with specifications as seen in \autoref{tab:tds7104}. It has GPIB interface and TekVISA GPIB, an API for sending GPIB commands over ethernet, available for remote control.
 
 \begin{table}[H]
-    \caption{Specs of the Tektronix TDS7104}
+    \caption{A selection of the specifications for the Tektronix TDS7104}
 \begin{adjustbox}{center}
     %\centering
     \begin{tabular}{|l|r|} 
@@ -393,8 +395,6 @@ The oscilloscope available for this project is a Tektronix TDS7104, with specifi
         \hline
         Channels & $4$ \\
         \hline
-        Interfaces & GPIB, TekVISA \\
-        \hline
     \end{tabular}
 \end{adjustbox}
     \label{tab:tds7104}
@@ -407,7 +407,7 @@ The oscilloscope available for this project is a Tektronix TDS7104, with specifi
 
 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
 \subsection{EM Test MPG 200 Micropulse generator}
-The MPG~200 is used to generate \emph{Test pulse 1} and \emph{2a}. MPG is an abbreviation for \emph{MicroPulse Generator}. The instrument is designed to generate test pulses according to the older ISO~7637-2:1990 version, but the parameters can be adjusted to comply with the new ISO~7637:1990 standard. The adjustable parameter ranges are shown in \autoref{tab:mpg200_specs}. The instrumentation panels can be seen in \autoref{fig:mpg200}.
+The MPG~200 is used to generate \emph{test pulse 1} and \emph{2a}. MPG is an abbreviation for \emph{MicroPulse Generator}. The instrument is designed to generate test pulses according to the older ISO~7637-2:1990 version, but the parameters can be adjusted to comply with the new ISO~7637:1990 standard. The adjustable parameter ranges are shown in \autoref{tab:mpg200_specs}. The instrumentation panels can be seen in \autoref{fig:mpg200}. It can be controlled via a GPIB interface.
 
 \begin{table}[H]
     \caption{Adjustable parameters in the MPG 200}
@@ -415,10 +415,10 @@ The MPG~200 is used to generate \emph{Test pulse 1} and \emph{2a}. MPG is an abb
     %\centering
     \begin{tabular}{|l|r|} 
         \hline
-        Parameter & Range \\
+        Parameter & Available settings \\
         \hline
         $U_S$  & \SIrange{20}{600}{\volt} \\
-        $U_S$ polarity & +, - \\
+        $U_S$ polarity & $+$, $-$ \\
         $R_s$  & \SIlist{2;4;10;20;30;50}{\ohm}  \\
         $t_1$  & \SIrange{0.2}{99.0}{\second} \\
         $t_2$  & \SIrange{0}{10}{\second} \\
@@ -448,7 +448,7 @@ The MPG~200 is used to generate \emph{Test pulse 1} and \emph{2a}. MPG is an abb
 
 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
 \subsection{EM Test EFT 200 Burst generator}
-The EFT~200 is used to generate \emph{Test pulse 3a} and \emph{3b}. EFT is an abbreviation for \emph{Electrical Fast Transient}. The instrument is designed to generate test pulses according to the older ISO~7637-2:1990 version, but the parameters can be adjusted to comply with the new ISO~7637:1990 standard. The adjustable parameter ranges are shown in \autoref{tab:eft200_specs}. The instrumentation panels can be seen in \autoref{fig:eft200}.
+The EFT~200 is used to generate \emph{test pulse 3a} and \emph{3b}. EFT is an abbreviation for \emph{Electrical Fast Transient}. The instrument is designed to generate test pulses according to the older ISO~7637-2:1990 version, but the parameters can be adjusted to comply with the new ISO~7637:1990 standard. The adjustable parameter ranges are shown in \autoref{tab:eft200_specs}. The instrumentation panels can be seen in \autoref{fig:eft200}. It can be controlled via a GPIB interface.
 
 \begin{table}[H]
     \caption{Adjustable parameters in the EFT 200}
@@ -456,11 +456,11 @@ The EFT~200 is used to generate \emph{Test pulse 3a} and \emph{3b}. EFT is an ab
     %\centering
     \begin{tabular}{|l|r|} 
         \hline
-        Parameter & Range \\
+        Parameter & Available settings \\
         \hline
         $U_S$  & \SIrange{25}{1500}{\volt} \\
-        $U_S$ polarity & +, - \\
-        Coupling & any combination of +, - and GND \\
+        $U_S$ polarity & $+$, $-$ \\
+        Coupling & any combination of $+$, $-$ and GND \\
         \hline
     \end{tabular}
 \end{adjustbox}
@@ -486,8 +486,8 @@ The EFT~200 is used to generate \emph{Test pulse 3a} and \emph{3b}. EFT is an ab
 \end{figure}
 
 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
-\subsection{EM Test LD 200 Load dump}
-The LD~200 is used to generate \emph{Load dump Test A}. LD is an abbreviation for \emph{Load Dump}. The instrument is designed to generate test pulses according to the older ISO~7637-2:1990 version, but the parameters can be adjusted to comply with the new ISO~16750:2012 standard. The adjustable parameter ranges are shown in \autoref{tab:ld200_specs}. The instrumentation panels can be seen in \autoref{fig:ld200}.
+\subsection{EM Test LD 200 Load dump generator}
+The LD~200 is used to generate \emph{load dump test A}. LD is an abbreviation for \emph{load dump}. The instrument is designed to generate test pulses according to the older ISO~7637-2:1990 version, but the parameters can be adjusted to comply with the new ISO~16750:2012 standard. The adjustable parameter ranges are shown in \autoref{tab:ld200_specs}. The instrumentation panels can be seen in \autoref{fig:ld200}. It can be controlled via a GPIB interface.
 
 \begin{table}[H]
     \caption{Adjustable parameters in the LD 200}
@@ -495,7 +495,7 @@ The LD~200 is used to generate \emph{Load dump Test A}. LD is an abbreviation fo
     %\centering
     \begin{tabular}{|l|r|} 
         \hline
-        Parameter & Range \\
+        Parameter & Available settings \\
         \hline
         $U_S$  & \SIrange{20}{200}{\volt} \\
         $R_s$  & \SIlist{0.5;1;2;10}{\ohm}  \\
@@ -520,16 +520,17 @@ The LD~200 is used to generate \emph{Load dump Test A}. LD is an abbreviation fo
 		\caption{Back.}
    	    \label{fig:ld200-back}
 	\end{subfigure}
-	\caption{The LD~200 is used to generate load dump test a.}
+	\caption{The LD~200 is used to generate load dump test A.}
     \label{fig:ld200}
 \end{figure}
 
 %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
 \subsection{EM Test CNA 200 Coupling Network}
-The SNA~200 is a coupling network used to multiplex the pulse generators outputs. It contains several relays to select the appropriate generator output. The SNA~200 has one interface for each pulse generator, but no interface for a computer. It is automatically controlled by the pulse generators. This allows the DUT to be connected only to the CNA~200 and not to each individual pulse generator. \autoref{fig:test_setup_cna_dut} shows the connections between the instruments in this setup. There is also a coaxial connection for calibration of pulse 3a and pulse 3b on the front panel. The instrumentation panels can be seen in \autoref{fig:cna200}.
+The SNA~200 is a coupling network used to multiplex the pulse generators outputs. It contains several relays to select the appropriate generator output. The SNA~200 has one interface for each pulse generator, but no interface for a computer. It is automatically controlled by the pulse generators. This allows the DUT to be connected only to the CNA~200 and not to each individual pulse generator. \autoref{fig:test_setup_cna_dut} shows the connections between the instruments in this setup. There is also a coaxial connection for calibration of pulse 3a and pulse 3b on the front panel. The instrumentation panels can be seen in \autoref{fig:cna200}. The CNA~200 have no controls or manual settings since it is controlled by the test generators that are attached to it via DSUB-connectors.
 
 \begin{figure}[H]
     %\captionsetup{width=.5\linewidth}
+    \centering
     \includegraphics[width=0.5\textwidth]{test setup pulse injection}    
     \caption{The CNA~200 allows each pusle generator to output their pulses through a common interface towards the DUT.}
     \label{fig:test_setup_cna_dut}
@@ -549,7 +550,7 @@ The SNA~200 is a coupling network used to multiplex the pulse generators outputs
 		\caption{Back.}
    	    \label{fig:cna200-back}
 	\end{subfigure}
-	\caption{The CNA~200 is used to couple all of the other pulse generators outputs to a common output.}
+	\caption{The CNA~200 is used to couple all of the other pulse generators outputs to a common output. The generators are connected using wires with \SI{4}{\milli\meter} banana connectors, except for the EFT~200 which has a high-voltage coaxial connector. The blue arrows illustrates the control signals from the generators to the CNA~200.}
    	\label{fig:cna200}
 \end{figure}
 

Certains fichiers n'ont pas été affichés car il y a eu trop de fichiers modifiés dans ce diff